Creating a Happy, Colorful, Handmade Home & life on the shores of lake superior

September 9, 2013

Planning to Paint a Brick Fireplace - Inspiration

No matter how much I pushed and prodded, and produced photo after photo of lovely painted brick fireplaces, Hubby never budged on the don't-paint-the-brick policy in the townhouse.  Given that there were so few things he was adamant about, decor-wise, I knew I would be entering serious bad-wife territory if I just primed and painted it when he wasn't looking (not that I didn't ponder it a time or two, paint brush in hand). 

When we bought the lakehouse, I was over the moon with the composite, concrete fireplace because it wasn't sacred, can't-paint-it brick.  Score!  Pass me a paint brush and let me have at it.


I immediately pictured charcoal grey paint covering the whole thing - knotty pine included - paired with freshly painted black fireplace doors and grates (goodbye gold).  Imagine my chagrin when Hubby vetoed painting this fireplace too!!  Womp wompHis reasoning: it matches the outside of the house.  My reasoning: that composite (and the siding) needs a dose of dark grey too!!

Now, I understand not painting stuff.  If the fireplace was chic and awesome, I'd leave it alone:

Reclaimed wood fireplace
Source
But ours is nothing special: it's builder's basic and isn't even real stone.

Concrete and pine fireplace

Someday I'd love to re-do the whole thing with something more modern and streamlined.  Drool:

Grey fireplace
Source
Smooth or stone or brick, I'm just really loving grey right now for a fireplace, and ours has such potential to look this gorgeous:

Emily Henderson
Warm grey fireplace
House and Home
black-brown brick fireplace
The Brick House
fireplace painted makeover
Kirsten Sessions Photography
fireplace painted makeover
The Best{H}Life
Like a bad kid, I already swiped on a stripe of primer (only on the pine!!), but I'll admit that I stood there, brush in hand, staring at the stone for a bit too long. 

We have to convince Hubby to come to the dark (grey) side.  Help?
SHARE:

31 comments

  1. we painted ours gray first thing when we moved in here... i have never regretted it and still love it 2 years (almost) later.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm jealous!! I think grey would be such a great neutral (and keep cleaner than white)! One vote for the grey, yay!

      Delete
  2. Paint the wall and woodstove, and the gold trim and see how it looks. It might surprise you. I'm certainly not opposed to painting brick but I have to say, yours isn't bad. I'm no help, am I? I'm so excited to see the after pictures of all the upcoming projects at the lake house. Okay, at second glance, I do love those gray fireplaces. Good luck convincing him.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. How am I going to hide this comment from Hubs, lol? The trim painted will definitely be a major improvement.

      Delete
  3. Dont paint the brick it is beutiful natural grey as it is. But do paint the Sauna colored wooden wall and the goldtrim. Love your blog.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hubby, is this you leaving an anonymous comment, LOL? It is definitely Sauna coloured - that is a perfect description!! Thanks for the input.

      Delete
  4. Painting the knotty pine will go a HUGE way! I like some of the painted fireplaces above, but hate a few of them too. Sometimes they can look too flat and one-dimensional with a simple swipe of paint. I'm on team "tear out and redo" ... of course, not right away.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tear out and redo is always a good option - if only it didn't come with such a scary price tag!! The pine is definitely gone - not even a question. I'm hoping a deeper grey has more impact than a swipe of mid-tone grey . . . The flatness is a good point to consider, and perhaps the finish plays a big role. A semi-gloss might be nicest . . .

      Delete
  5. You know, what I want to know is what is up with the weird double vents with the shelf underneath?? This wouldn't be so bad if those vents weren't there and the shelf was even with the other two.

    Also painting the concrete a darker color would hide the soot accumulation from the fireplace you have going on there. And it's only going to get darker as time goes by. I say paint it!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The vents are weird looking, right? Sadly, it's a whole system that moves and circulates the heat from the fireplace so more heats the space and not the sky above. I am hoping black vents with dark grey paint will make them disappear a little. I'm also hoping they work so friggin' awesomely good, I can forgive their ugliness.

      Yay for the darker colour vote!! Hiding the soot is definitely another concern of mine.

      Delete
  6. You have to convice him to let you paint it or cover it or something. That blotchy brown grey situation just doesn't seem like your style at all. Plus it doesn't make any sense with the white tile situation in front of it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes yes!! The white tile has grey in it that doesn't show up well on camera. I'd like to replace it with some dark grey slate eventually, so that whole area is a yummy charcoal grey focal point.

      Delete
  7. I would def paint it - it would change a lot in the way it looks. I, however, would paint everything white and paint the wood in a very subdued grey, but I think your plan would work really well too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I always love white fireplaces - and the wood painted pale grey would look so pretty! My only concern is keeping it clean. It's sooty right now from the former owner . . . not sure if that is a user-error or a flaw in the design?? It's smoky for some reason, something our townhouse wood burning fireplace never was. But white would be so crisp!! Great idea :)

      Delete
  8. Maybe this will convince Hubby in a bass-ackwards way: I'm middle-aged and really don't like those gray fireplaces. So if you want to go youthful, go gray!

    Absolutely yes on painting the pine and getting rid of the gold. I *could* support darkening the brick, closer to the smoked look right above the fireplace--but not losing the variations in color. I guess the flat is what throws my "old" brain.

    Looking forward to seeing your first round of results! Maybe I'll even come over to the dark(er) side...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Your reasoning is so sweet!! I agree: the variations are nice. Some of the inspiration pics are a little flat. But a lot of younger readers don't seem to love the grey either, so I wouldn't discount your taste as "old" at all.

      Delete
  9. maybe you will not hate it as much if you replace the mantel, or will he compromise and you can paint the ledge and replace the mantel? and of course still paint that pine and gold?!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pine and gold are definitely outta there (shudder). New mantle?? Such a good idea!!

      Delete
  10. How about a compromise "greywashing" of the brick? I've just been admiring the job YHL did on their orangey brick fireplace at http://www.younghouselove.com/2013/08/whitewash-in-the-hizzy/.... and can't help thinking that instead of whitewash, using a grey paint (albeit watered down) would preserve the dimensionality of the brick. If the original brick showed through just a smidge, would that satisfy your life's partner? A darker stain/paint on the shelves would help you out a lot, too, once the gold and sauna pine are gone. Take it in stages and see if he doesn't come around.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Greywashing is a fun idea!! I love that everyone calls the wood "sauna pine". That cracks me up every time.

      Delete
  11. Wear. Him. Down! It took me almost 7 years to get the go ahead on painting my kitchen cabinetry. It was worth it! Good Luck! M.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Haha!! You know, once he saw these photos, he phoned me and admitted he thought the fireplace surround was nicer than he remembered. He's only seen the house a few times. Seeing the first painted brick fireplace convinced him!! But I'll need to go super bold and dark, I think, to keep it from looking flat like others pointed out.

      Delete
  12. Another vote for paint it grey... and I love the charcoal grey. Of the houses we've been purusing, many that have brick fireplaces, we're quickly painted white in my brain (too many red brick and others, as you describe, builder basicy). But the grey- doh! Why wasn't I mentally painting them grey? I love grey and definitely love the charcoal examples you've posted. Not to mention the practicality of masking the soot.
    And I like the suggestion of greywashing (but still dark grey)- perhaps that could prevent it from potentially looking flat. Easy enough to do a test area and if it doesn't work, it could then be painted solid.

    Oh I hope that hubby agrees in the end- this would be so beautiful with a little (modern) facelift.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have always thought white, too, until I saw the grey fireplace at The Brick House and fell in love. Because I'm such a white wall fanatic, I think I need the dark grey over white, or else the fireplace will disappear. I'm excited to tackle this, but focusing on painting the room, first. We haven't moved yet, so painting without furniture (esp. ceilings) is a dream!!

      Delete
  13. I'm all for painting that fireplace!! HUBBY YOU MUST ALLOW THIS!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  14. yuck! Good luck with the painting- perhaps not a big deal for you. Some people love painting, I on the other hand, hate it. Especially ceilings!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't love it at all. I am also a big mess when I paint - sloppy and careless. I've gotten paint in my eye (and I wear glasses, so that's a major feat right there). But my parents are helping and the transformation is worth the suffering, lol.

      Delete
  15. Oooh, I agree with you. Grey would look fantastic! I think your hubby will change his mind soon enough :) Crossing my fingers for you!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Oooh, I agree with you. Grey would look fantastic! I hope your hubby changes his mind soon!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Oh gosh... he needs to improve his argument. "because it matches the outside" doesn't hold up. a) you'd never see the two together b) fireplace brick screams to be painted.
    I doubt I helped... but I hope he changes his mind!!

    ReplyDelete

You've made my day - I love hearing from you! I approve comments only to keep out the spam, so don't worry if your comment doesn't pop up right away.

© Dans le Lakehouse | All rights reserved.
See What Inspires Me on Pinterest